FYI: Got an email that he's out of the office until 11/18/19

EQ: 11/6
ER: 11/7
YA Fantasy 75K

YA Fantasy 72k
DVpit request
EQ: 10/28
ER: 11/6

EQ: 11/4
ER: 11/5, form

Comic Fantasy 84K

EQ: 10/24
ER: 10/25, form

Fantasy 92K

Thanks KIKIKIKI

Here's the link to that interview:
https://writeordiepodcast.com/2019/09/23/s2-episode-4-jim-mccarthy-rejected-both-of-us/

To everyone submitting to Jim -- I HIGHLY recommend listening to Write or Die's podcast episode interviewing him. He gives really good insight and explains his logic behind choosing/rejecting submissions.

EQ: 09/16/19
FR: 09/17/19, sent same day
ER: 10/08/19, form

Form rejection on a full kind of really sucks because it was #MSWL and he'd requested to see future works earlier. Well. Moving on...

YA Contemporary, 85k

EQ: 10/5
FR: 10/7

YA fantasy 84k. at least it was quick :)

EQ 100,000 urban fantasy 9/25/19

ER 10/1/19 ( "Dear Author" Form )

Doesn't 'fit list' despite Jim Tweeting a #MSWL .

No personalization of authors name like Topherghost056 got. :( And sorry to hear about no personalization for a full!

"Thanks so much for letting us take a look at your materials and please forgive us for responding with a form letter. The volume of submissions we receive, however, makes it impossible to correspond with everyone personally.

Unfortunately, the project you describe does not suit our list at this time. We wish you the best of luck in finding an agent and publisher for your work and we thank you, once again, for letting us consider your materials."

EQ: 09/30
ER: 10/01, form

Adult Fantasy 80K

EQ: 2019-09-30
ER: 2019-10-01 (Form: "Dear Author")

Hi tophersghost056,

That sucks and is not a reflection of your writing.
Good luck on your journey.

Form rejection on full manuscript. Clearly not good enough to garner even a sentence of personalization.