EQ: 11/13/18
ER: 12/04/18
Personalized kind form rejection from assistant Genevieve
MG Contemporary Supernatural Mystery
57,000 words

EQ: 11/8 2018
Request for full 11/14 2018
Rejection with feedback 11/19 2018

EQ: 11/7

January, 2017: rejection on full

10/8: emailed Genevieve (Amy's assistant) and asked if she'd take another look at my completely revised manuscript (I have no shame!)
10/9: Genevieve kindly agreed to read the first 100 pages
10/11: sent revised 100 pgs in PDF format (per request)
10/22: upon offer of rep from another agent, requested full manuscript
11/5: kind step-aside

83K YA gothic mystery

EQ: 8/12
PR: 9/6 - 100 pages (sent 9/7, confirmation of receipt 9/11)

Personalized rejection w/ feedback: 10/18

Pretty disappointed. Would have really liked a chance at an R&R.

EQ: 10-3
Closed 10-18 as people after me have gotten responses.
YA action adventure 74k

EQ -- 10/3/18
Full request per Genievive 10/8/18

EQ: 09/12/18
ER: 10/05/18

Not sure if form.

"Thank you very much for sending your query for BOOK NAME to Amy Berkower, and for your patience while we considered it.
Amy appreciated the opportunity to review your project, but unfortunately she is unable to offer representation at this time. Despite the many virtues of your work, it doesn’t feel like a fit for her list.
Please remember that this is only one opinion in a highly subjective business and another agency may feel differently. Good luck in finding representation, and thank you for thinking of Writers House."

Contemporary Romance, 70k words

Here's my timeline (touches on the below comments, too):

Queried - 1/22/18
Full request - 1/22/18
Exclusive R&R offer from Genevieve (In-House Editor at WH and Amy's associate) - 1/29/18
*I had six other fulls out, so needed time to figure out how to handle that - took two weeks and then accepted the exclusive*
Notes from Genevieve received (less than two weeks after accepting exclusive - very quick!) - 2/28
Revision sent back - 6/12
Note from Genevieve saying she loved it and is going to show it to Amy / if Amy passes, am I okay with her showing to other agents at WH (to which I replied: yes, of course!) - 7/31
Note from Genevieve saying Amy passed but she had shown it to Andrea Morrison and she was VERY interested - 8/6
SIGNED WITH ANDREA - 8/7/18

A couple things:

a) If you are offered it, doing an exclusive R&R with them will make your manuscript SO much stronger (Genevieve's notes are invaluable).
b) They do result in offers.

@elle_em

I understand that it's disappointing to do major revisions and then get rejected. But to be honest, I would be stoked to get free, professional editorial feedback, even if it was on an exclusive basis and the manuscript didn't work out in the end. Maybe it would mean taking a break from querying other agents for a few months, but considering the time it takes to write a good novel, I really wouldn't care.

EQ: 05/31/2018

PR: 100pg request from Genevieve same day.

ER: 07/12/18. Feel super gutted by this one, but REALLY appreciate how specific Genevieve's rejection was. With references to the MS, she pointed out what she loved, and what she didn't love. This was the first query I ever sent out, and my first request, so even though I'm disappointed, I'm so happy they gave it this much thought. A few tears and a bucket of ice cream, that's what I need.....


MG

@horrorchix89: She doesn't hate fantasy (yours or anyone's). It's just that as far as I know, Amy no longer represents YA fantasy.

EQ: 5/3
PR: 5/8 from Genevieve (50 pages)
Asked if I had any other requests out.
ER: 5/18 Personal Feedback. Issues with world building. Oh well

Updating this because I was going to query a new project, but reread the rejection letter. Genevieve told me not to send them fantasy. Not sure if it's just MY fantasy she hates or everyones. Just a heads up for YA Fantasy writers

YA Dark Fantasy 89k

The person who manages her submissions, Genevieve Gagne, just wrote this on twitter:

"Absolutely 100 percent make sure your email address is working before you e-query! I just requested a book I was excited about, and got multiple bounce backs saying my reply was undeliverable."

Eeegads maybe check your email address? Send yourself an email from another address.

EQ: 3/23/18
ER: 4/17/18
Contemporary Romance 71K
Form letter