Here's what agents are saying about The Modern Guide to Querying Literary Agents...   
Warning: Be aware of scammers impersonating real agents. Learn how to spot them.

Ms. J.D. Myall

The Tobias Literary Agency

What's the best way to query this agent?

Get answers to this, and many more agent questions at QueryTracker.

Closed to Unsolicited Queries
General

J.D. Myall

The Tobias Literary Agency

New York
Website:
thetobiasagency.com
Query Methods
Accepts queries via...
QueryManager [Go To Form]
Submit Query
Closed to Unsolicited Queries
Genres
This agent is seeking the following genres:

Fiction

Action/Adventure
Children's
Commercial
Contemporary
Family Saga
Fantasy
  • Fantasy, Contemporary/Urban
  • Fantasy, Magical Realism
Graphic Novel
Historical
Horror
Humor/Satire
LGBTQ+
Middle Grade
  • Middle Grade, Contemporary
  • Middle Grade, Fantasy
  • Middle Grade, Historical
  • Middle Grade, Mystery
  • Middle Grade, Science Fiction
Multicultural
Mystery
New Adult
Picture Book
Romance
  • Romance, Category
  • Romance, Contemporary
  • Romance, Historical
  • Romance, Paranormal
  • Romance, Thriller/Suspense
Science Fiction
Thrillers/Suspense
Upmarket
Women's Fiction
Young Adult
  • Young Adult, Christian
  • Young Adult, Contemporary
  • Young Adult, Fantasy
  • Young Adult, Historical
  • Young Adult, Mystery
  • Young Adult, Paranormal
  • Young Adult, Paranormal Romance
  • Young Adult, Romance
  • Young Adult, Science Fiction

Non-Fiction

Art/Photography
Biography
Cookbook
Cultural/Social Issues
Current Affairs/Politics
Pop Culture
Join Now (FREE) to learn more about this agent. (Such as how often and how quickly each agent replies to queries.)



Known Clients (current & past)
Author Comments
Comments by authors about this agent.
Wilson32
11/20/2026 10:04 AM
"I am sorry to have such bad news, but querying is an inherently subjective and self-loathing process. I am afraid you are not a good fit for who I want handling my intellectual property. So I am going to have to withdraw my submission. I am sure another writer will feel differently. Good luck on your search for a client."



unreliable_narrator
11/20/2026 10:01 AM
I’m one of the people who was contacted about a call in early October, with no follow-up until mid-November. I decided to withdraw from consideration. The agent has shown poor judgment and erratic behavior, and the agency has clearly not given her the training or oversight that was needed.

As a side note, every communication I received from the agent was a bland form letter with no personalization beyond inserting my name and the title of my novel. I confirmed with others that they received exactly the same messages. I was actually surprised to see that someone’s full ms rejection that they pasted here contained more detail about their manuscript than I received in her message asking for a call. I don’t need to have my ego inflated, but I found it odd that someone who had allegedly read my full ms and wanted to talk to me about it would express no enthusiasm for it or mention any detail about it. I had a weird feeling about this agent from the outset, partly due to the impersonal communication. Trust your gut, and good luck out there.
writingbubbly
11/20/2026 08:36 AM
Here is a respone someone got from Lane, head of Tobias after reaching out about J.D. originally posted on Reddit, I don't know if it will help anyone:

The owner responded. Copy and pasted the response below:

Hi ___,

Hope all is well and you had a good weekend. I wanted to send you the same update of our investigations as I have others. We spoke with J.D. who assured us she did not upload any manuscripts to AI — she is an author herself so was horrified to hear this — but seems that due to the prior issues of ghosting on calls (which we also addressed with her) she overcompensated by scheduling far too many* *calls and was confused by the notes in front her of while on said call.

We take this incredibly seriously and going forward will have her close to queries and increase training and oversight with regular training and co-repping current projects with senior agents (including myself).

Again, this is the utmost concern to us. Having a fiduciary duty to clients and a moral one to all authors, we recognize it's an incredible honor and responsibility to be intrusted with an author's manuscript.

If you have any other concerns or suggestions, please let us know. Of course, maintaining your confidentiality is of the utmost importance.

I hope this assuages any concerns, and please let me know if anything else comes up.

L
trinityaliciaa
11/19/2026 12:19 PM
Love it @Wilson32 it’s like using their language right back at them!
Klausner
11/19/2026 04:38 AM
What are you all writing in your withdrawals? Like, obviously she knows, but...

More author comments available to members.

Join Now (Free)
Agent Interviews
Interviews with this agent from across the web.

None found for this agent

Success Story Interviews
Read interviews with authors who have signed with this agent.

None found for this agent


View all success story interviews

Report a success story

Profile History
Last Update:
11/16/2026 - Closed to queries.
Disclaimer
Always verify agent's information before sending your query, and review the agent's website(s) for more up-to-date information.

Though we do our best, QueryTracker can not guarantee the accuracy of any information provided.

An agent listing on QueryTracker is not an endorsement or recommendation of that agent by QueryTracker.

Before contacting an agent, authors should verify and assess the agent's requirements and suitability by visiting the agent's website(s), and becoming familiar with ways to spot and avoid bad agents. A good place to start is Writers Beware, a watch group that helps inform and protect authors from shady practices.