Here's what agents are saying about The Modern Guide to Querying Literary Agents...   
Warning: Be aware of scammers impersonating real agents. Learn how to spot them.

Ms. Sarah Jane Freymann

Sarah Jane Freymann Literary Agency

How long does it take this agent to reply to a query?

Get answers to this, and many more agent questions at QueryTracker.

General

Sarah Jane Freymann

Sarah Jane Freymann Literary Agency

59 West 71st Street, Suite 9B
New York, NY 10023
E-Mail:
To protect agents from spam, email addresses are hidden except to members.
Join Now
Website:
www.sarahjanefreymann.com
AALA Member:
No
Query Methods
Accepts queries via...
E-Mail
Genres
This agent is seeking the following genres:

Fiction

Commercial
Literary Fiction
Young Adult

Non-Fiction

Cookbook
Food/Lifestyle
Health/Fitness
Journalism
Memoir
Multicultural
Narrative
Nature/Ecology
Parenting
Psychology
Religion/Spirituality
Self-Help
Travel
Women's Issues
Join Now (FREE) to learn more about this agent. (Such as how often and how quickly each agent replies to queries.)



Known Clients (current & past)
Enid Abrhami
Pam Ammondsen
David Anderson
Coleman Andrews
David Andrusia
Robin Asbell
John Ash
Rick Askins
John Baeder
David Bank
Carlos Bentos
Sidney Le Blanc
Brenda E. Brasher
Rita Milos Brownstein
Robert Caputo
Glenn Chu
Dexter Cirillo
Lena Claxton
Dawn Davenport
Marc David
Carl Dellatore
Tom Dolby
Diana Durham
Seppo Ed Farrey
Salvatore Fichera
Stephen Foehr
Christine Frissora
Jocelyn Fujii
Jenny Fujita
Ansu Gebeh
Rena Kornreich Gelissen
Diane Gerhart
Leslie Glass
Marshall Glickman
Tom Grant
Stephanie Elizondo Griest
Elaine Gross
Linda Hawes
Steven Heller
Steve Heller
Linda Hogan
Laurel Holliday
Jan Johnsen
Steven Johnson
Kirk Byron Jones
Sherry Kahn
Kevin Keim
Katherine Ketcham
David Kherdian
Patricia Klindienst
Jana Kolpen
Aglaia Kremezi
Katherine Kurs
Robert Latkany
Helen Lee
Cyndi Lee
Warren Lehrer
Marc Lesser
Melba Levick
Laura Levin
Jane Lidz
Karen Lindsey
Laurie Lisle
Ralph Lopez
Heather Dune Macadam
Patricia Madson
Mary Marcus
Susanna Margolis
Francesco Mastalia
Jarvis Masters
Linda Mayer
Charles Mayer
Stephanie McCarthy
Michael McLauglin
Linda Trichter Metcalf
Sy Montgomery
Charles W. Moore
Pamela Morgan
Gary Nabhan
Agate Nesaule
Kim Nicholson
Carol O'Biso
Myochi Nancy O'Hara
John O'Hara
Nancy O'Hara
Ruth Orkin
Alfonse Pagano
Daniel Patterson
Katherine Payne
Victor Perera
Brenda Peterson
Rolf Potts
Debra Prinzig
Rosa Ross
Fred Rottman
Robert Rummel-Hudson
Dick Russell
Brad E. Sachs
Brad Sachs
Zalman Schacter-Shalomi
Robert M. Schoch
Steven Schwartz
Gail Sher
Jerome Singer
Dorothy Singer
Mark Sloany
Estelle Sobel
Lavinia Spalding
Mirabai Paula Starr
Nancy Stedman
Tommy Steele
Amy Stein
David Strah
Celia Straus
Schmuel Tatz
Mary Tiegreen
Dan Tobin
James Victore
Justine Walsh
Lisa Wassong
Lauren R. Weinstein
Melissa Gayle West
Nina Wise
Tad Wise
Jeffrey P. Wittmann
Alison Woo
Sue Woodman
Marvin Woods
Kenneth Wydro
Su-Mei Yu
Lora Zarubin
Jonathan Zuess
Author Comments
Comments by authors about this agent.
CandraCampbell
08/26/2026 05:18 AM
8/26/26

Received a personalized rejection letter, explaining what was working, and ultimately what wasn't, within 32 minutes of sending the query along with a really helpful Pitchcraft letter. I truly appreciate agents like this.
Botanica
08/26/2026 04:32 AM
Q: 7/4/26
R: 8/26/26

The only agency to respond with anything remotely personalized after months of querying. Even sent a little guide on what this Katharine person believes agents look for. Mad props. A personalized rejection is nice. A personalized acceptance is better. :)
ddf1989
08/25/2026 01:24 PM
Query sent AUGUST 25/2026

YA speculative, 93k words

Did not receive a confirmation email. Is that typical for this agency?

Good luck to everyone on your querying journeys ❤️
writethrowclay
08/25/2026 08:26 AM
UPDATE: Since Katharine sent me a highly personalized rejection for one novel, I decided to query her with my other novel. She got back to me the same day (yesterday), also with a very personalized rejection. Her response was incredibly helpful, and I intend to change my query to address the points she mentioned. I wish her response had been a request, but I'm very grateful for her words, as they opened my eyes to some things I wasn't seeing. I will definitely query this agency with my next novel. I'm feeling very encouraged and excited to finish my current WIP.

I received a very personalized email rejection from Katherine Sands (even though I sent my original email query to Sarah Jane). Despite being rejected, I was absolutely thrilled to get any response from her, since it looks like from the Data Explorer tool that not many authors receive a response, or at least return here to log it. This means she found my query at least worthy of a serious look (rare in this age of mass-purges, and no-response=rejection).

The feedback was legit and applicable, with the exception of one part. A specific thing happens to my character repeatedly through the novel, which is part of the mystery and story arc, and isn't revealed until the end of the novel. Katharine wrote, "the distinctive logic behind [this character's specific event] remained too withheld for me." So I'm left wondering if the agency wanted more of a full synopsis, in which I reveal the spoilers... or if I need to adjust my query letter to focus harder on the fact that this event is part of the mystery that needs to be solved. (Note: I probably will adjust my query, at least a little bit).

EQ: 5/22/26 YA-mystery
CNR: 8/22/26
ER (personalized): 8/23/26

octobercountryresident
08/24/2026 09:22 PM
Q: 7/18
R: 8/22
2nd R: 8/24

Although personalized, I wasn't going to comment about this since the personalization struck me, as skluci08 said, as inferring too much. However today (8/23), I received a rejection for a query I sent on 5/22 and had marked as CNR. Not only did I receive a rejection from this agency for the first time since I first queried in 2016, I received two!

Edit: Received a second rejection for my 7/18 query. This rejection focused more on personal preference against my manuscript's pessimistic themes (apparently failure is lower stakes than success). This isn't too bad, and other agents have expressed similar sentiments. However, Katharine also included a craft essay, complete with a registered trademark, with helpful bon mots such as "The most successful first pages orient, engage, and propel". I appreciate the sentiment, but how is revising my query going to change the agent's opinions on thematic matters? "Your manuscript sounds too sad and depressing for my tastes; Pivot and propel! Who, where, when, and why!"
More author comments available to members.

Join Now (Free)
Agent Interviews
Interviews with this agent from across the web.

None found for this agent

Success Story Interviews
Read interviews with authors who have signed with this agent.

Teresa Rhyne


View all success story interviews

Report a success story

Profile History
Last Update:
01/21/2021 - Genres updated.
Disclaimer
Always verify agent's information before sending your query, and review the agent's website(s) for more up-to-date information.

Though we do our best, QueryTracker can not guarantee the accuracy of any information provided.

An agent listing on QueryTracker is not an endorsement or recommendation of that agent by QueryTracker.

Before contacting an agent, authors should verify and assess the agent's requirements and suitability by visiting the agent's website(s), and becoming familiar with ways to spot and avoid bad agents. A good place to start is Writers Beware, a watch group that helps inform and protect authors from shady practices.