Introducing a new writing tool from the maker of QueryTracker.
Learn More...
Introducing a new writing tool from the maker of QueryTracker. Learn More...

Ms. Caitlin McDonald

Donald Maass Literary Agency

Should you query this agent?

Get answers to this, and many more agent questions at QueryTracker.

Closed to Unsolicited Queries

Caitlin McDonald

Donald Maass Literary Agency

1000 Dean Street, Suite 252
Brooklyn, NY 11238
Twitter (X):
AALA Member:
Yes (Visit Site)
Query Methods
Accepts queries via...
QueryManager [Go To Form]
Submit Query
Closed to Unsolicited Queries
This agent is seeking the following genres:


  • Fantasy, Contemporary/Urban
  • Fantasy, Magical Realism
Graphic Novel
  • Romance, Fantasy
Science Fiction
Young Adult
  • Young Adult, Contemporary
  • Young Adult, Fantasy
  • Young Adult, Historical
  • Young Adult, Mystery
  • Young Adult, Science Fiction


Join Now (FREE) to learn more about this agent. (Such as how often and how quickly each agent replies to queries.)

Known Clients (current & past)
Julesd Devito
Lara Elena Donnelly
Kate McIntyre
Sandra Odell
Cl Polk
Crystal Schubert
Caitlin Starling
Author Comments
Comments by authors about this agent.
12/07/2023 01:58 PM
Queried 120k new adult fantasy romance retelling Sept 2023, received a kind form rejection Dec 7 2023
12/07/2023 01:58 PM
Q: 9/1
FR: 12/6

87k YA contemporary fantasy (LGBTQ+ romance)

12/07/2023 07:32 AM
Queried 9/1
Form Rejection 12/6

A SF 86,000
12/06/2023 05:47 PM
Query submitted 9/1/23
Nudge 11/30/23 (Day 90)

Form rejection 12/6/23

She also said that she is not currently doing submission feedback meetings with marginalized authors as she is about to go on medical leave for 3 months.

74k dark fantasy fairytale retelling
12/06/2023 05:34 PM
Query Submitted 9/1/23
Nudge 12/4/23 (Day 94)

Worst she can do is reject anyways!

12/6/23 - rejection, nudging works!

More author comments available to members.

Join Now (Free)
Agent Interviews
Interviews with this agent from across the web.

None found for this agent

Success Story Interviews
Read interviews with authors who have signed with this agent.

Jules Devito

CL Polk

Amber Pierce

View all success story interviews

Report a success story

Profile History
Last Update:
09/08/2023 - Closed to queries.
Always verify agent's information before sending your query, and review the agent's website(s) for more up-to-date information.

Though we do our best, QueryTracker can not guarantee the accuracy of any information provided.

An agent listing on QueryTracker is not an endorsement or recommendation of that agent by QueryTracker.

Before contacting an agent, authors should verify and assess the agent's requirements and suitability by visiting the agent's website(s), and becoming familiar with ways to spot and avoid bad agents. A good place to start is Writers Beware, a watch group that helps inform and protect authors from shady practices.